Heat pumps or gas heaters: The Great Heating War 2025!

Lörrach, 14.06.2025: SPD-Politiker diskutiert Vor- und Nachteile von Wärmepumpen gegenüber Gasheizungen im Kontext neuer Gesetzgebung.
Lörrach, June 14, 2025: SPD politicians discussed the advantages and disadvantages of heat pumps compared to gas heating in the context of new legislation. (Symbolbild/MBW)

Heat pumps or gas heaters: The Great Heating War 2025!

In an increasingly heated debate about heating technologies, the SPD politician has recently had a clear position. While he still relies on gas heating in his own home, he warns against dismissing heat pumps as a serious option. "The heat pump is a clever solution, especially for older houses," he says, criticizing the negative reporting on this technology. According to Lies ’opinion, enlightenment is essential in order not to let the social debate drift negatively, such as Verlagshaus-Jaumann.de

The discussion between sponsors and opponents of gas heating and heat pumps is also initiated by the new building energy network (AGE), which will come into force at the turn of 2024. It promotes the change from fossil fuels to renewable energies. In the future, heating with fossil fuels from 2045 will be prohibited nationwide. But until municipal heat planning can still be selected between the two heating systems. In many existing buildings, gas heating is still permitted for the time being, which initially makes the decision easier for many owners.

Costs at a glance

In view of the rapidly increasing energy costs, heat pumps are considered in the long term as more economically more advantageous. Studies show that their operating costs can be obvious more cheaply over a period of 20 years than that of gas heating. The acquisition costs for a heat pump are between 15,000 and 30,000 euros, while at gas heaters you have to expect 6,000 to 15,000 euros. The subsidies offered by the federal government also make the change to the heat pump attractive, so utopia.de.

  • energy source: heat pump: air, electricity; Gas heating: natural gas
  • energy costs (in 20 years): heat pump: approx. 20,000 - 31,000 euros; Gas heating: approx. 28,000 - 56,000 euros
  • CO2 costs (in 20 years): heat pump: none; Gas heating: approx. 15,600 euros
  • greenhouse gas emissions: heat pump: approx. 8.9 kg CO2E/sqm/year; Gas heating: approx. 43 kg CO2E/sqm/year

long -term perspectives

The switch to heat pumps could not only be ecologically but also financially useful, since it is predicted that gas prices rise while electricity prices may drop. The Rhineland-Palatinate Consumer Center confirms that heat pumps are cheaper after about 10 to 15 years. The CO2 prices and the rising network charges will also have an impact on the costs of gas heating, such as "https://www.erdgas-suedwest.de/natuerlichtukunft/waermepumpe-gasheiz-kostenvergleich/"> natural gas-suedwest.de

The decision for a heating system should not be hastily made. With the impending ban on fossil fuels, it is clear that investments in sustainable technologies could make sense both ecologically and economically in the long run. It remains exciting how the discussion will develop and what solutions owners will ultimately choose.

Details
OrtLörrach, Deutschland
Quellen